No history yet

Existential Nihilism

Transcript

Beau

So, we've seen Macbeth just completely unravel. The ghost, the sleeplessness, the tyranny... it feels like we're just waiting for the big, final battle where the good guys win.

Jo

And we get that. Malcolm does become king, order is technically restored. But Shakespeare does something so much more interesting than just a simple 'good versus evil' finale. He uses Macbeth's final moments to pivot into this... vast, existential void.

Beau

The void. Right. That doesn't sound very triumphant. Is that where the famous speech comes in? The 'Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow' one?

Jo

Exactly. He's just been told that Lady Macbeth is dead, and his reaction isn't grief. It's... numbness. He says, 'She should have died hereafter; There would have been a time for such a word.' He's basically saying, 'Oh. Well, that would have mattered yesterday, but not today.'

Beau

Because nothing matters anymore.

Jo

Precisely. And that kicks off the soliloquy. 'Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow, Creeps in this petty pace from day to day'. Think about that rhythm. It's not a march; it's a slow, monotonous crawl. He sees time not as a line progressing forward, but as this pointless, repetitive cycle leading to nothing.

Beau

That's a total reversal from the beginning, isn't it? In the beginning, time was everything. He was obsessed with the future, with what the witches prophesied he would *become*.

Jo

Yes! He killed Duncan to speed up linear time, to get to the endpoint—the crown—faster. But now, having done all that, he realizes that endpoint was meaningless. All he's left with is this cyclical, empty repetition of 'tomorrow.' It's pure nihilism.

Beau

So, nihilism is basically the belief that life is meaningless? Can you ground that for me?

Jo

Of course. Imagine you spend your whole life climbing a mountain because you believe something incredible is at the top. You sacrifice everything—friends, integrity, sleep. When you finally get to the peak, you find... it's just a rock. And it's identical to the rock at the bottom. That crushing realization that the entire journey had no purpose? That's Macbeth's headspace.

Beau

Wow. Okay. And that's where he gets to the 'poor player' metaphor, right?

Jo

Yep. 'Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player that struts and frets his hour upon the stage and then is heard no more.' He sees his own life—his ambition, his murders, his kingship—as just a bad actor, over-emoting for a brief moment before vanishing forever. It's a performance for an empty theater.

Beau

And the final line of that... 'a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.' That's about as bleak as it gets.

Jo

It's the ultimate collapse of meaning. All the noise, the violence, the 'sound and fury' of his entire story... it adds up to zero. Which is so ironic, because at the same time, he's still clinging to the witches' prophecies for meaning. He still believes he's invincible.

Beau

Oh, right! The 'none of woman born' and the Birnam Wood thing. He thinks he's found a loophole in fate, but fate has a loophole for his loophole.

Jo

It's the ultimate act of equivocation, which we talked about earlier. The prophecies were literally true, but not in the way he understood them. Birnam Wood *does* come to Dunsinane when the soldiers carry branches. And Macduff *was* from his mother's womb 'untimely ripp'd'—a C-section. He put his faith in a trick of language, and it led him to this meaningless end.

Beau

So even though Malcolm takes the throne and everything seems fine, the play doesn't really end on a happy note. It leaves you with this... scar.

Jo

That's the perfect word for it. The political order is restored, but we've just spent five acts inside the mind of a man who concluded that existence itself is bankrupt. You can't just put that back in the box. The kingdom is healed, but the play shows that the potential for that kind of nihilistic collapse is always there, under the surface of things.

Beau

It's not a cautionary tale just about not killing kings. It's a cautionary tale about... losing the 'why'.

Jo

Exactly. Once Macbeth's ambition severed him from his own humanity, from his connection to others, all that was left was the mechanics of power. And he discovered, too late, that the mechanics themselves mean nothing at all.