No history yet

Strategic Control Selection

From Risk to Resilience

Once you've identified your organization's risks, the next step is to choose the right tools to manage them. This isn't about buying the latest software or creating a mountain of paperwork. It's about strategic control selection: picking the precise security measures that counter your specific threats without crippling your operations. Think of it like a doctor choosing a treatment plan. A diagnosis (risk assessment) is critical, but the cure depends on selecting the right combination of therapies (controls).

Two of the most respected playbooks for this are and ISO/IEC 27001. They aren't checklists to be blindly followed; they are comprehensive catalogues of security controls. NIST SP 800-53, for example, groups controls into 20 different families, covering everything from Access Control (AC) and Incident Response (IR) to Physical and Environmental Protection (PE). Each family contains a set of individual controls that can be implemented to reduce risk in that area.

ISO/IEC 27001 takes a slightly different approach. Its famous Annex A provides a list of control objectives and controls. While NIST is often seen as more prescriptive, ISO is more focused on building a holistic Information Security Management System (ISMS), where you select controls from Annex A based on the outcomes of your risk assessment. The goal is the same: to build a defensive structure that is right-sized for your organization.

Tailoring Your Armour

No two organizations are identical, so a one-size-fits-all security plan is doomed to fail. This is where tailoring and scoping come in. After selecting a baseline set of controls from a framework like NIST, you must customize it. Scoping involves determining which parts of your organization the controls will apply to. For example, a public-facing web server needs a different set of protections than an internal HR database.

Tailoring involves modifying the control baseline to fit your specific operational environment and risk appetite. You might decide that a recommended control is not technically feasible or cost-effective. In these cases, you might use —alternative measures that still satisfy the original security requirement. For instance, if encrypting a legacy database is impossible, you might implement stricter access controls, enhanced logging, and network segmentation around it to achieve a similar level of protection.

The key is justification. You can't just ignore a control; you must replace its protective value with something else and document why.

Defense in Depth

Effective security isn't about finding one perfect control. It's about layering different types of controls to create a robust, multi-layered defense. This strategy, known as 'Defense in Depth', ensures that if one control fails, others are still in place to stop an attack. These layers are built by balancing different types of controls.

Lesson image

The primary balance is between technical and administrative controls.

  • Technical (or Logical) Controls are the hardware and software mechanisms used to protect assets. Think firewalls, intrusion detection systems, and encryption.
  • Administrative (or Managerial) Controls are the human-driven policies, procedures, and practices. This includes security awareness training, incident response plans, and background checks.

A firewall (technical) is great, but it's much more effective when supported by a strong password policy (administrative) and employees trained not to click on phishing links (administrative). Likewise, an incident response plan (administrative) is useless without the logging and monitoring tools (technical) needed to detect a breach in the first place.

Controls are also categorized by their function:

  • Preventive controls aim to stop an incident from occurring (e.g., access control lists).
  • Detective controls aim to identify an incident after it has occurred (e.g., security camera footage).
  • Corrective controls aim to limit the damage and restore systems after an incident (e.g., data backups).
Control TypeFunctionTechnical ExampleAdministrative Example
PreventiveStop incidents before they happenFirewall rulesPre-employment screening
DetectiveIdentify incidents during or afterIntrusion Detection System (IDS) logsRegular internal audits
CorrectiveLimit impact and recoverRestoring from backupsIncident Response Plan execution

A mature security strategy doesn't rely on just one type. It uses preventive controls to block most attacks, detective controls to catch what gets through, and corrective controls to ensure a swift recovery. The art of control selection is finding the right mix that addresses your specific risks within your budget and operational constraints.

Now, let's test your understanding of these concepts.

Quiz Questions 1/6

What is the primary goal of strategic control selection in risk management?

Quiz Questions 2/6

An organisation's security policy requires all employees to undergo annual security awareness training. This is an example of what type of control?