No history yet

Introduction to Proofs

What is a Proof?

In mathematics, a proof is a rock-solid argument that a statement is true. It’s not just about showing your work or trying a few examples. A proof is a chain of logical steps, starting from things we already know or assume to be true, that leads to an undeniable conclusion. Think of it like a lawyer building a case, but with numbers and symbols instead of evidence and witnesses. Every step must follow logically from the one before it, leaving no room for doubt.

The starting points for proofs are called axioms or postulates. These are statements we accept as true without proof, like “the shortest distance between two points is a straight line.” From these axioms, we build up more complex truths called theorems. A proof is the bridge that connects the axioms to the theorem.

Theorem

noun

A mathematical statement that has been proven to be true based on axioms and previously established theorems.

The statement we want to prove usually takes the form of a conditional statement: "If P, then Q." The part "P" is called the premise or hypothesis, and "Q" is the conclusion. The proof's job is to show that whenever P is true, Q must also be true.

Direct Proof

The most straightforward way to build this bridge is with a direct proof. You start by assuming the premise (P) is true and then use definitions, axioms, and logical steps to show that the conclusion (Q) must follow. It’s a step-by-step march from A to B.

Let's prove a classic statement: If you add two even integers, the sum is even.

Our premise (P) is: We have two even integers. Our conclusion (Q) is: Their sum is an even integer.

First, we need a precise definition of an even integer. An integer is even if it can be written as 22 times some other integer. For example, 6=2×36 = 2 \times 3 and 14=2×714 = 2 \times 7.

Now let's build the proof:

  1. Assume the premise is true. Let's take two even integers, we'll call them xx and yy.
  2. Using our definition, we can write x=2ax = 2a and y=2by = 2b for some integers aa and bb.
  3. Now, let's look at their sum: x+yx + y. We can substitute our expressions for xx and yy.
x+y=2a+2bx + y = 2a + 2b
  1. We can factor out a 2 from the right side.
x+y=2(a+b)x + y = 2(a + b)
  1. Since aa and bb are integers, their sum (a+b)(a + b) is also an integer. Let's call this new integer kk. So, x+y=2kx + y = 2k.

Because the sum can be written as 22 times an integer (kk), the sum is, by definition, an even number. We've directly proven that the sum of any two even integers is always even. The logic is airtight.

Indirect Proofs

Sometimes, the direct path from P to Q is hard to find. It might be blocked or hidden. In these cases, mathematicians use clever detours called indirect proofs. Instead of tackling the problem head-on, we can approach it from a different angle. We'll look at two common types: proof by contrapositive and proof by contradiction.

These methods feel a bit like a logic puzzle, and they are powerful tools for proving tricky statements.

Proof by Contrapositive

Every "If P, then Q" statement has a logically equivalent partner called the contrapositive: "If not Q, then not P." If one is true, the other is automatically true as well. Sometimes, proving the contrapositive is much easier than proving the original statement.

Consider a simple, non-math example: "If it is raining, then the ground is wet." The contrapositive is "If the ground is not wet, then it is not raining." Both statements say the same thing. Proving one is the same as proving the other.

Let's try proving a mathematical statement using this method: If n2n^2 is an even integer, then nn is an even integer.

A direct proof is tricky. If we assume n2n^2 is even, we can write n2=2kn^2 = 2k. Then n=2kn = \sqrt{2k}. It's not immediately obvious why that means nn has to be even.

So, let's try the contrapositive. First, we write it down:

  • Original Statement: If n2n^2 is even (P), then nn is even (Q).
  • Contrapositive: If nn is not even (not Q), then n2n^2 is not even (not P).

"Not even" is just another way of saying "odd." So, we need to prove: If nn is odd, then n2n^2 is odd. This is much easier and looks like a direct proof problem.

  1. Assume nn is odd. By definition, an odd integer can be written as 2k+12k + 1 for some integer kk.
  2. So, we set n=2k+1n = 2k + 1.
  3. Now we square it:
n2=(2k+1)2 =(2k+1)(2k+1) =4k2+4k+1n2=2(2k2+2k)+1\begin{aligned} n^2 &= (2k + 1)^2 \ &= (2k + 1)(2k + 1) \ &= 4k^2 + 4k + 1 \\ n^2 &= 2(2k^2 + 2k) + 1 \end{aligned}
  1. Let the integer inside the parenthesis, 2k2+2k2k^2 + 2k, be called mm. Then n2=2m+1n^2 = 2m + 1.

This expression, 2m+12m+1, is the definition of an odd number. We have successfully proven that if nn is odd, then n2n^2 is odd. Because we've proven the contrapositive, we have also proven the original statement.

Proof by Contradiction

This method is another powerful indirect technique. It's a bit like playing devil's advocate with the statement you're trying to prove. The process goes like this:

  1. Assume that the statement you want to prove is actually false.
  2. Follow the logical consequences of this assumption.
  3. Show that this path leads to a contradiction—something impossible, like $1=0$ or a number being both even and odd.
  4. Since your initial assumption led to nonsense, the assumption must be wrong. Therefore, the original statement must be true.

Let's prove one of the most famous results in mathematics: The square root of 2 is an irrational number.

An irrational number is one that cannot be written as a fraction ab\frac{a}{b} where aa and bb are integers and the fraction is in simplest form.

  1. We start by assuming the opposite. Assume that 2\sqrt{2} is rational.
  2. This means we can write 2=ab\sqrt{2} = \frac{a}{b} where aa and bb are integers with no common factors (the fraction is fully simplified).
  3. Let's square both sides: 2=a2b22 = \frac{a^2}{b^2}.
  4. Multiply by b2b^2 to get 2b2=a22b^2 = a^2.
  5. This equation tells us that a2a^2 is an even number (since it's 2 times something). From our contrapositive proof earlier, we know that if a2a^2 is even, then aa must also be even.
  6. If aa is even, we can write it as a=2ka = 2k for some integer kk.
  7. Now, substitute 2k2k for aa in the equation from step 4:
2b2=(2k)2 2b2=4k2 b2=2k2\begin{aligned} 2b^2 &= (2k)^2 \ 2b^2 &= 4k^2 \ b^2 &= 2k^2 \end{aligned}
  1. This new equation shows that b2b^2 must be even, which means bb must also be even.

Here comes the contradiction. We've concluded that both aa and bb must be even. But at the very beginning, we assumed that the fraction ab\frac{a}{b} was in simplest form, meaning aa and bb have no common factors. If they are both even, they share a common factor of 2. This is a contradiction!

Our assumption that 2\sqrt{2} is rational led to a logical impossibility. Therefore, the assumption must be false.

The only possible conclusion is that 2\sqrt{2} is irrational.

Quiz Questions 1/5

What is the fundamental purpose of a mathematical proof?

Quiz Questions 2/5

When using a direct proof to prove the statement 'If P, then Q', what is the first step?

These proof techniques are the building blocks of mathematical reasoning. They allow us to build a solid foundation of knowledge, where each new truth rests securely on the ones that came before.