No history yet

Sustainable Withdrawal Math

The Golden Goose Equation

Let's start with a clear financial target. You have a $5 million portfolio, and you need it to fund a specific lifestyle for the next 25 years. Your annual budget is $190,000, which covers $70,000 in living expenses and a $120,000 travel fund. The first step is to figure out what percentage of your total nest egg you'll be withdrawing each year.

Annual WithdrawalTotal Portfolio Value=Withdrawal Rate\frac{\text{Annual Withdrawal}}{\text{Total Portfolio Value}} = \text{Withdrawal Rate}

Plugging in our numbers, the calculation is straightforward.

$190,000$5,000,000=0.038=3.8%\frac{\$190,000}{\$5,000,000} = 0.038 = 3.8\%

Think of your $5 million portfolio as a goose that lays golden eggs. The $190,000 you withdraw each year is a very valuable egg. Our entire goal is to keep collecting these eggs for 25 years. To do that, we must protect the goose at all costs. If we take too much money out, especially when the market is down, we risk shrinking the principal investment. This is the equivalent of cooking the goose. A smaller goose lays smaller eggs, and eventually, no eggs at all. So, the 3.8% rate isn't just a number; it's the pace we've set for our goose.

The 4% Rule and Today's Reality

For decades, retirees have relied on the as a guideline. This simple rule suggests that you can withdraw 4% of your portfolio in your first year of retirement and then adjust that amount for inflation each following year, with a high probability of your money lasting for 30 years. Based on this, your $190,000 withdrawal (3.8%) seems perfectly safe, as it's below the 4% threshold of $200,000.

This rule says, based on historical performance, that you can withdraw 4% of your nest egg annually, and likely not run out of money for at least 30 years.

However, the financial landscape has changed. Recent research from institutions like Morningstar suggests that for new retirees in 2024 and 2025, the (SWR) is closer to 3.7%. Why the drop? It's due to two main factors: high equity valuations and lower bond yields. In simple terms, stocks are priced high, which often signals lower future growth, and bonds (the traditional safe haven) are not paying out as much as they used to. This combination makes it harder for a portfolio to replenish itself after withdrawals.

Your target of 3.8% is just slightly above this new, more conservative 3.7% benchmark. This doesn't mean your plan is doomed; it just means there is very little room for error. It requires careful portfolio management and a disciplined approach to withdrawals. You also have to account for inflation. While your budget is $190,000 today, the cost of living and travel will likely increase over 25 years. That fixed dollar amount will buy less and less over time, a challenge we'll need to address.

Quiz Questions 1/4

Given a $5 million portfolio and planned annual withdrawals of $190,000, what is the annual withdrawal rate?

Quiz Questions 2/4

In the 'goose that lays the golden eggs' analogy, what does 'cooking the goose' represent?