No history yet

Complex Employment and Personal Tax

Employer-Provided Automobiles

When an employer provides an automobile that an employee can use personally, a taxable benefit must be calculated and included in the employee's income. This benefit has two components: the standby charge and the operating cost benefit.

The standby charge reflects the value of having the car available for personal use. It's calculated whether the employee uses the car or not. The calculation depends on whether the employer owns or leases the vehicle.

Benefit=2%×Original Cost×Months Available\text{Benefit} = 2\% \times \text{Original Cost} \times \text{Months Available}

For a leased automobile, the calculation is based on the lease payments.

Benefit=23×Lease Payments×Days Available30\text{Benefit} = \frac{2}{3} \times \text{Lease Payments} \times \frac{\text{Days Available}}{30}

There's a potential reduction to the standby charge if the employee's personal use is minimal. This applies if the car is used more than 50% for business and personal travel is less than 1,667 kilometers per month (20,004 km annually). The standby charge is then multiplied by the ratio of personal kilometers to this threshold.

Next is the operating cost benefit, which covers employer-paid expenses like gas, maintenance, and insurance. The CRA offers two ways to calculate this.

Benefit=Prescribed Rate×Personal Kilometers\text{Benefit} = \text{Prescribed Rate} \times \text{Personal Kilometers}

Alternatively, if the automobile is used more than 50% for business purposes, the employee can elect to have the operating cost benefit calculated as half of their standby charge. This is often beneficial when personal driving is high but business use still exceeds the 50% threshold.

Employee or Contractor?

Determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor is critical, as it significantly affects tax obligations for both the worker and the payer. Employees have income tax, CPP, and EI deducted at source, while contractors are responsible for their own remittances. The CRA uses a four-point test to assess the relationship, looking at the total picture rather than a single factor.

FactorEmployeeIndependent Contractor
ControlPayer directs how and what is done.Worker has autonomy over work methods.
Ownership of ToolsPayer provides the necessary tools.Worker provides their own tools.
Profit/Loss RiskNo risk of loss; paid a salary/wage.Can realize a profit or incur a loss.
IntegrationWorker is an integral part of the business.Worker performs a specific, separate service.

No single factor is decisive. A court or the CRA will weigh all four based on the specific facts of the working relationship. The written contract is considered, but the actual day-to-day reality of the relationship holds more weight.

Deducting Work-Related Expenses

Certain employment and work-related expenses can be deducted from income, but the rules are highly specific.

For employees, a key requirement for deducting most employment expenses is having a signed Form T2200, Declaration of Conditions of Employment, from their employer.

One common deduction is for home office expenses. For an employee to qualify, their home workspace must be either their principal place of work (more than 50% of the time) or used exclusively and regularly for meeting clients or customers. If they qualify, they can deduct a portion of household running costs, like utilities and rent, based on the square footage of the office space. However, employees cannot deduct mortgage interest, property taxes, or home insurance.

Moving expenses are another technical deduction. To be eligible, the move must be for work, business, or post-secondary education, and the new home must be at least 40 kilometers closer to the new work or school location. Eligible expenses include travel costs, temporary living expenses (up to 15 days), and costs of selling the old residence. The deduction is limited to the income earned at the new location in that year, but any unused portion can be carried forward.

Property Income and Attribution

Income from property, such as rent from a real estate investment or dividends from stocks, is taxed differently than income from a business. The line between property income and business income can sometimes be blurry.

Property income is generally considered a return on invested capital that requires minimal effort. For instance, owning a single rental property managed by a third party typically generates property income. Business income, on the other hand, involves significant activity and effort. Owning and actively managing a large apartment complex with many services provided to tenants would likely be considered a business.

Lesson image

To prevent high-income individuals from unfairly reducing their tax burden, the CRA has attribution rules. These rules prevent income splitting by transferring income-producing assets to family members in lower tax brackets.

If you lend or transfer property to your spouse or a related minor (under 18), any resulting property income is typically attributed back to you and taxed in your hands. For example, if you give shares to your spouse, the dividends from those shares are taxed as your income, not theirs. This rule applies to first-generation income (the dividends) but not second-generation income (income earned by reinvesting the dividends).

An important exception: The attribution rules do not apply if the property is sold or loaned at fair market value and, in the case of a loan, interest is charged at the prescribed rate. If these conditions are met, the income is taxed in the hands of the family member who received the property.

These complex areas require careful attention to detail. Understanding the nuances is key to accurate tax preparation and planning.

Ready to test your knowledge?

Quiz Questions 1/6

An employee uses an employer-provided car for business 60% of the time and 40% for personal trips. The employer pays for all gas and maintenance. Which of the following is true regarding the operating cost benefit?

Quiz Questions 2/6

When determining if a worker is an employee or an independent contractor, a written contract stating they are a contractor is the most decisive factor for the CRA.

Mastering these topics is a big step forward in your CPA journey. Keep focusing on the details and the reasoning behind each rule.