No history yet

Mapping the Third Space

The Space Between

Space is more than just a physical location. It's a complex blend of the material world, our ideas about that world, and our lived experiences within it. To understand this, we can turn to a powerful concept: the Third Space. This isn't one single idea, but a meeting point for three thinkers who, from different fields, arrived at a similar conclusion. We'll weave together the work of post-colonial theorist Homi Bhabha, urban geographer Edward Soja, and sociologist Ray Oldenburg to map this transformative territory.

Soja provides the foundational map with his 'spatial trialectics'. He argued that we typically only think about space in two ways.

Firstspace is the physical, tangible world. It’s the concrete streets, buildings, and parks you can touch and measure. It is space as it is perceived.

Secondspace is the conceptual world. It’s the architect’s blueprint, the city planner’s zoning map, the laws governing property, or the mental image you have of your neighbourhood. It is space as it is conceived or imagined.

For a long time, we stopped there. We saw the world as a tension between the 'real' and the 'ideal'. But this misses the most important part: how we actually live.

Lesson image

Lived Reality

This is where Soja’s crucial third term comes in. Thirdspace is lived space. It's the dynamic, messy, and often contradictory reality that emerges from the collision of the physical and the conceptual. It’s not just the street (Firstspace) or the map of the street (Secondspace); it's the protest march that floods the street, the festival that reclaims a car park, the way children turn a set of stairs into a playground. Thirdspace is where the rules are bent and new meanings are created.

Ray Oldenburg’s concept of 'third places' offers a tangible example. He identified informal social hubs—cafes, pubs, libraries, parks—that are distinct from the private sphere of home (the 'first place') and the structured environment of work (the 'second place'). These are quintessential Thirdspaces. They are physical locations that are charged with social and cultural energy, becoming vital for community, debate, and identity formation.

The power of Thirdspace lies in its potential to challenge the established order. It's a space of possibility, where what is meets what could be.

However, these vital social hubs are under threat. Modern productivity culture tends to erode any space that isn't optimised for work or consumption. Public benches are designed to be uncomfortable to prevent loitering. Parks are privatised for ticketed events. Cafes discourage lingering with a lack of power outlets or aggressive table-clearing. When every space is either home or a place of transaction, the informal, community-building fabric of Oldenburg's third places starts to fray.

Thirding as Othering

This brings us to Homi Bhabha's contribution. He wasn't talking about pubs or city parks, but about the psychological and cultural space created by colonialism. For Bhabha, the Third Space is a site of hybridity, where the coloniser's culture and the colonised's culture meet and create something new and unsettling to both. It's a space that resists easy categorisation and challenges the binary logic of 'us vs. them'.

When we synthesise these ideas, we arrive at a powerful critical tool: 'Thirding-as-Othering'. This is the conscious act of looking for and creating a third option to break down a restrictive binary. It moves beyond just a location to become a way of thinking and being. Instead of choosing between the physical world (Firstspace) and the world of ideas (Secondspace), Thirding finds the lived reality that combines and transcends them. Instead of the binary of home or work, it finds community. Instead of 'self' vs. 'other', it finds hybrid identity.

Emphasizes praxis, combining theory with concrete action for social transformation

This practice allows us to identify our own eroded third spaces. It might be a literal place, like a community square that's now a car park. Or it might be a psychological zone, like the time between clocking off from work and arriving home, which is now filled with work emails on your phone. By viewing these spaces through the lens of Thirding, we see them not just as lost locations, but as lost opportunities for resistance, connection, and the creation of new meaning.

Time for a quick check on these interconnected concepts.

Quiz Questions 1/7

According to Edward Soja's spatial trialectics, what best describes 'Thirdspace'?

Quiz Questions 2/7

A city government creates a zoning map designating a public square for commercial use only (Secondspace). The physical square itself is paved and has benches (Firstspace). A group of citizens then begins using the square for weekly, unsanctioned community picnics. What does this activity represent?

Understanding the Third Space is about more than academic theory. It's a way of seeing the world in three dimensions, recognising the hidden spaces where life happens and where change becomes possible.